1
Who is most likely to...
forget to turn off the lights on the Christmas tree
Christmas Most Likely To Questions: Fun Holiday Prompts
Grab your favorite mug, cue the carols, and dive into a festive round of Most Likely To. This collection of Christmas-themed prompts is designed to spark laughter, nostalgia, and wholesome debates as friends and family gather. Each question targets one person and leans into relatable holiday quirks, making your game nights merry and memorable.
Draw from the deck below or scroll to browse all questions
All 100 Questions
2
Who is most likely to...
accidentally drop a gift and pretend it was wrapped that way
3
Who is most likely to...
eat all three types of cookies in one sitting
4
Who is most likely to...
lose count of how many days till Christmas
5
Who is most likely to...
sing too loudly in the car while caroling
6
Who is most likely to...
overlook a return policy at the last minute
7
Who is most likely to...
forget the secret Santa recipient
8
Who is most likely to...
burn the popcorn string while decorating
9
Who is most likely to...
accidentally send a text to the wrong person about a gift
10
Who is most likely to...
leave the hot cocoa mug in a random room
11
Who is most likely to...
misplace one ornament every year
12
Who is most likely to...
still believe in Santa despite the adults’ jokes
13
Who is most likely to...
mix up the Christmas cards and the birthday cards
14
Who is most likely to...
host the best cookie exchange without planning ahead
15
Who is most likely to...
stay up all night wrapping gifts
16
Who is most likely to...
underline a bow with tape instead of string
17
Who is most likely to...
confuse mistletoe with a decoration and stand under it
18
Who is most likely to...
accidentally reuse gift wrap from last year
19
Who is most likely to...
make an overly ambitious Christmas playlist
20
Who is most likely to...
dramatically reread a sentimental card aloud
21
Who is most likely to...
forget to take the tree down after New Year
22
Who is most likely to...
help wrap gifts with too much tape
23
Who is most likely to...
become the designated hot cocoa refiller
24
Who is most likely to...
keep the Christmas lights on all day by accident
25
Who is most likely to...
decorate the tree with non-ornamental snacks
26
Who is most likely to...
train the pets to pose with the gifts
27
Who is most likely to...
pull a prank by disguising a gift as a gag
28
Who is most likely to...
burn the cookies but insist they’re still delicious
29
Who is most likely to...
remember every gift by the color ribbon
30
Who is most likely to...
get caught under the same bow twice
31
Who is most likely to...
have the best Christmas sweater collection
32
Who is most likely to...
mistake a gift for a different person and swap it back
33
Who is most likely to...
hide a present in the freezer for safekeeping
34
Who is most likely to...
start an argument over the Christmas playlist
35
Who is most likely to...
break a fragile heirloom ornament and blame the cat
36
Who is most likely to...
volunteer to host but regret the planning
37
Who is most likely to...
end up with mismatched sock gifts
38
Who is most likely to...
forget the Christmas Eve dinner menu
39
Who is most likely to...
improvise a dessert with leftovers
40
Who is most likely to...
return a gift you actually loved
41
Who is most likely to...
become the family photographer for all selfies
42
Who is most likely to...
resolve to start a new tradition and forget it next year
43
Who is most likely to...
lose track of time while wrapping late at night
44
Who is most likely to...
have the most elaborate Christmas cookies
45
Who is most likely to...
accidentally order extra gift bags and never use them
46
Who is most likely to...
be the one who reads the Christmas story aloud
47
Who is most likely to...
decorate the tree with homemade ornaments
48
Who is most likely to...
get glitter all over the house during craft hour
49
Who is most likely to...
forget to water the poinsettias
50
Who is most likely to...
compete in a secret Santa but keep the budget tiny
51
Who is most likely to...
steal a bite of someone else’s Christmas pudding
52
Who is most likely to...
teach kids a carol they’ll remember for years
53
Who is most likely to...
turn a Christmas card into a tiny piece of art
54
Who is most likely to...
overexplain the meaning of Christmas gifts
55
Who is most likely to...
choose a themed gift for the gift exchange
56
Who is most likely to...
spend hours on a Christmas puzzle
57
Who is most likely to...
accidentally break a favorite ornament and pretend it adds character
58
Who is most likely to...
make the best hot cider from scratch
59
Who is most likely to...
decide to wrap gifts in newspaper for a rustic look
60
Who is most likely to...
misplace the Santa hat just before a photo
61
Who is most likely to...
make a last-minute cake for Christmas brunch
62
Who is most likely to...
forget where they hid the last present for a scavenger hunt
63
Who is most likely to...
stick to a strict 5-minute cookie baking rule
64
Who is most likely to...
manage to toast the perfect marshmallow
65
Who is most likely to...
share a Christmas miracle story that makes everyone teary
66
Who is most likely to...
build a gingerbread house that barely stands
67
Who is most likely to...
lose count of how many cards they sent
68
Who is most likely to...
bring a gift only to realize it’s for the wrong person
69
Who is most likely to...
reinvent a traditional dish with a modern twist
70
Who is most likely to...
have the quietest Christmas due to a peaceful snow day
71
Who is most likely to...
abruptly switch from playlists to live music
72
Who is most likely to...
accidentally spill cocoa on a gift wrap table
73
Who is most likely to...
promise to start Christmas shopping earlier next year
74
Who is most likely to...
become the go-to gift wrapper in the family
75
Who is most likely to...
have a perfect-exact recipe for peppermint bark
76
Who is most likely to...
keep the tree up too long into January
77
Who is most likely to...
confess a childhood Christmas mischief
78
Who is most likely to...
find the perfect stocking stuffer at the last minute
79
Who is most likely to...
host a flawless Secret Santa reveal
80
Who is most likely to...
forget to set an alarm and miss the caroling start
81
Who is most likely to...
learn a new Christmas tradition from a friend
82
Who is most likely to...
redecorate the entire living room after a playful argument
83
Who is most likely to...
make the most heartwarming plate of holiday treats
84
Who is most likely to...
be the person who corrects everyone’s pronunciation of ‘wassail’
85
Who is most likely to...
turn the annual gift exchange into a game show
86
Who is most likely to...
play Santa and forget to tell the kids the truth
87
Who is most likely to...
discover a sentimental Christmas piece they thought was lost
88
Who is most likely to...
cope with a last-minute travel plan during the holidays
89
Who is most likely to...
be the only one who sticks to a diet during holiday feasts
90
Who is most likely to...
accumulate a pile of Christmas-themed mugs
91
Who is most likely to...
fix a broken string of lights with tape and faith
92
Who is most likely to...
keep a running list of would-be gifts for next year
93
Who is most likely to...
find joy in delivering surprise gifts to neighbors
94
Who is most likely to...
complete a holiday craft that impresses the family
95
Who is most likely to...
host a midnight movie marathon on Christmas Eve
96
Who is most likely to...
get roped into a spontaneous family photo shoot
97
Who is most likely to...
perfect a signature Christmas cocktail
98
Who is most likely to...
reveal a long-held secret under the mistletoe
99
Who is most likely to...
choose a gift that finally wins over the toughest relative
100
Who is most likely to...
have the most creative tree-topper choice
Showing 100 questions
Ready to Play?
Use these questions in your next game or create your own custom themed questions
Play Most Likely To OnlineWhy This Theme Works
Christmas brings a wealth of traditions, cozy moments, and quirky habits that are instantly recognizable. The themed questions tap into holiday rituals, gift-giving details, and seasonal mischief, which makes players feel seen and understood. The format naturally sparks stories and inside jokes, whether someone inevitably overshares their baking disasters or secretly loves wrapping presents late at night.
Best Occasions
These questions shine at family Christmas gatherings, office holiday parties, or cozy friend-travel get-togethers. They work best with 6–12 players for dynamic turns and lively discussion. Mix lighthearted prompts about baking mishaps with a few thoughtful ones about giving and gratitude to balance the energy and keep everyone engaged throughout the evening.
With these Christmas-themed Most Likely To prompts, your holiday game night will sparkle with laughter, warmth, and a dash of friendly competition. Use them to spark stories, celebrate quirks, and create lasting memories together. Grab some cocoa, gather your crowd, and let the festive conversations begin!