250+ This or That Questions: The Ultimate Collection for Every Occasion
Coffee or tea? Beach or mountains? Texting or calling? The simplest questions often reveal the most about who we are. This or That isn't just a game of binary choices – it's a window into personality, values, and the quirky preferences that make each person unique. Whether you're breaking the ice at a party, diving deep on a road trip, or spicing up date night, the right This or That questions transform awkward silence into genuine connection.
The magic lies in its simplicity. No elaborate rules, no equipment, no pressure to perform. Just two options and the fascinating discovery of where people land. But here's what most people get wrong: they stick to boring, predictable questions that everyone's heard a thousand times. We've compiled 250+ fresh, creative This or That questions organized by exactly what you need – from conversation starters that work with strangers to spicy choices that deepen intimacy with close friends.
Why This or That Works
Unlike games requiring long explanations or complex scoring, This or That delivers instant engagement. The forced choice format makes people commit to an answer, which naturally leads to the real gold: the "why" behind their choice. That's where stories emerge, debates spark, and connections deepen.
Plus, everyone participates equally. Introverts appreciate the structure. Extroverts enjoy the discussion. And watching a group split 50/50 on a controversial choice? That's when the real fun begins.
How to Play This or That (Rules & Variations)
The beauty of This or That is its flexibility. Here are the core ways to play, from casual to structured:
Basic Rules:
- The Classic: Someone asks a This or That question, everyone answers, then shares why they chose that option
- Speed Round: Rapid-fire questions with no explanations – just gut reactions and watching patterns emerge
- Physical Movement: At parties, have people move to different sides of the room based on their choice (great for visual engagement)
- Guess First: Before revealing your choice, guess what the other person will say – builds empathy and understanding
- Debate Mode: After choosing, each side makes their best case for why their option is superior
Creative Variations:
- Assumption This or That: Guess what someone else would choose before they answer – reveals how well you know each other
- Story Time: Every choice must come with a related story or memory
- Themed Rounds: Dedicate rounds to food, travel, relationships, hypotheticals, etc.
- Dealbreaker Edition: For each choice, discuss if dating someone with the opposite preference would be a dealbreaker
- Switch Challenge: Defend the option you didn't choose – great for perspective-taking
Digital Twist: Want to level up your This or That game? Use VoteMostLikely.com for organized voting, instant results on the big screen, and access to curated question libraries. Perfect for large groups or virtual parties!
Easy This or That Questions (Perfect Icebreakers)
Start here if you're with new people, warming up a group, or just want light, fun conversation. These this or that icebreaker questions work for any age and any setting:
Funny This or That Questions (Guaranteed Laughs)
These funny this or that questions are designed to be ridiculous, absurd, and conversation gold. Perfect when you want to keep things light and entertaining:
Deep This or That Questions (Meaningful Conversations)
When you're ready to go beyond surface level, these deep this or that questions reveal values, priorities, and worldviews. Perfect for close friends, long car rides, or late-night conversations:
This or That Questions for Couples (Romantic & Revealing)
These this or that questions for couples help you understand each other's preferences, dreams, and quirks. Perfect for date nights, road trips, or just deepening your connection:
Spicy This or That Questions (For Bold Friends)
Ready to turn up the heat? These spicy this or that questions are for groups comfortable with each other and ready for some revealing, bold choices. Keep it fun and respectful:
This or That Questions for Friends (Group Fun)
Perfect for friend hangouts, game nights, or whenever you want to learn something new about people you thought you knew everything about:
Random This or That Questions (Unique & Unexpected)
When you want to keep everyone guessing with creative, unusual choices that spark the most interesting discussions:
Hard This or That Questions (Impossible Choices)
These hard this or that questions create genuine dilemmas where there's no easy answer. Watch people squirm as they try to choose:
Food This or That Questions (For the Foodies)
Because food preferences reveal so much about personality, and these questions always lead to passionate defenses:
Pop Culture This or That Questions
Test allegiances and spark friendly debates with these pop culture showdowns:
Pro Tips for Playing This or That
For the Best Conversations:
- Start Easy, Go Deeper: Begin with light questions to build comfort, then gradually increase the depth or spiciness
- The Follow-Up is Gold: The real conversation happens when you ask "why?" – that's where stories and debates emerge
- No Wrong Answers: Create a judgment-free zone where people feel safe revealing their true preferences
- Mix Categories: Don't stay in one category too long – variety keeps energy high
- Watch for Patterns: It's fascinating to see if someone consistently chooses adventure over comfort, or logic over emotion
- Adapt to Your Audience: Read the room – if people're loving deep questions, stay there. If they want silly, deliver silly
For Different Settings:
- First Dates: Stick to easy and food questions with a few carefully chosen deep ones
- Friend Groups: Mix funny and spicy with some random ones for variety
- Family Gatherings: Focus on easy, food, and clean random questions
- Long Car Rides: Perfect time for deep and hard questions that spark long discussions
- Parties: Funny and random work best with large groups for energy and laughs
- Team Building: Use icebreaker questions followed by a few that reveal work styles and values
Advanced This or That Techniques:
- Custom Questions: Create personalized This or That questions based on shared experiences with your group
- Tournament Style: Have people defend their choice, then vote on who made the best case
- Reverse Psychology: After everyone answers, ask them to convince the group why the opposite choice is actually better
- Storytelling Round: Each choice requires sharing a relevant personal story
- Dealbreaker Edition: Discuss whether choosing differently would be a dealbreaker in friendships or relationships
- Speed Dating Format: Pair people up for rapid-fire This or That, then rotate partners
Why This or That Questions Work So Well
There's actually psychology behind why this simple game creates such great moments:
- Forced Choice Creates Clarity: Unlike open-ended questions where people can deflect or give vague answers, This or That demands commitment to an opinion
- Binary Choices Reveal Values: How people navigate tough choices shows what they prioritize and value most
- Low Stakes, High Engagement: There's no pressure to perform or be clever – just pick one and explain why
- Creates Natural Debates: When groups split on controversial choices, organic discussions happen without anyone feeling attacked
- Unexpected Discoveries: You learn surprising things even about people you've known for years
- Levels Social Playing Field: Introverts and extroverts can participate equally – no one dominates
Taking This or That to the Next Level
Once you've mastered basic This or That, try these creative variations to keep the game fresh:
Would You Rather Hybrid:
Blend This or That with Would You Rather by adding consequences. "Coffee or tea, but you can never have the other one again?" Suddenly stakes are higher and choices get harder. Want to go all-in on this format? Check out our 300+ Would You Rather questions for scenarios with impossible choices and hilarious dilemmas.
Most Likely To Crossover:
After everyone answers a This or That question, vote on who in the group is "most likely to" stick to their choice or flip under pressure. Try it with our Most Likely To questions for even more fun!
Assumption Game:
Before revealing your choice, have everyone guess what you'll pick. Reveals both who knows you well and who's full of surprises.
Never Have I Ever Edition:
Turn This or That physical: "Cats or dogs? Everyone who chose cats, drink!" Works great at parties. Check out our Never Have I Ever questions for more party game inspiration.
Timed Challenge:
Give 3 seconds to answer – gut reactions often reveal more than carefully considered responses.
This or That questions might seem simple, but they're powerful tools for connection. Whether you're breaking the ice with strangers, deepening bonds with close friends, or just passing time on a road trip, the right questions transform ordinary moments into conversations you'll remember. Start with the easy ones, work your way to the deep or spicy ones, and watch as simple binary choices reveal the complexity and uniqueness of the people around you.
Ready for More Party Game Fun?
This or That is just the beginning. Want to level up your party game collection? Try Most Likely To – the ultimate group game that combines voting, predictions, and hilarious revelations. Perfect for any group size, any occasion, and guaranteed to create unforgettable moments.
Play Most Likely To Now - Free & Easy!More from Party Games
100 Most Likely To Questions: The Ultimate Party Game List
Looking for the perfect questions to spark laughter and reveal hilarious truths about your friends? Our curated list of 100 'Most Likely To' questions will transform any gathering into an unforgettable party experience.
Read more →Top 10 Icebreaker Games for College Students (with Online Options)
Transform awkward dorm introductions into genuine friendships with these proven icebreaker games. Perfect for RAs, study groups, and virtual orientations - no cringe-worthy name games required!
Read more →10 Fun Drinking Games to Play at Your Next Party
Ready to level up your party game? These creative drinking games go way beyond beer pong and flip cup. From question-based classics to high-energy competitions, here's how to keep the good times flowing (responsibly, of course).
Read more →